near me
California Penal Code 198 PC – Self-defense Killings

CALIFORNIA PENAL CODE 198 PC – SELF-DEFENSE KILLINGS

Los Angeles Criminal Defense LawyerAccording to California Penal Code 198 PC, it is not sufficient justification for killing someone in self-defense or defense of others based on a “bare fear.” To be considered justifiable, individuals must reasonably believe that they or others are in immediate danger of being killed or seriously injured, and that using deadly force is necessary to prevent it.

Engaging in a killing solely out of bare fear, without reasonable justification, can lead to charges of first-degree murder. Convictions for this offense can result in a sentence of 25 years to life in prison, with or without the possibility of parole.

When someone kills another person based on an honest but unreasonable belief in the necessity of using deadly force for self-defense, it is known as “imperfect self-defense.” However, imperfect self-defense is not a valid defense against a charge of murder.

Penal Code 198: A bare fear of the commission of any of the offenses mentioned in subdivisions 2 and 3 of Section 197, to prevent which homicide may be lawfully committed, is not sufficient to justify it. But the circumstances must be sufficient to excite the fears of a reasonable person, and the party killing must have acted under the influence of such fears alone.

Source: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=PEN&sectionNum=198

UNDERSTANDING SELF-DEFENSE LAWS IN CALIFORNIA

Under California law, the use of lethal force in self-defense is considered legal only if certain conditions are met:

  • The person defending themselves must genuinely believe that they or someone they love were in immediate danger of being injured, killed, or forced to commit a crime against their will.
  • The person must reasonably believe that immediate and lethal force was necessary to prevent the impending danger.
  • The individual must not use more force than what is reasonably necessary against the alleged attacker.
See also  CALIFORNIA PENAL CODE 1192.7 PC - SERIOUS FELONIES UNDER THREE-STRIKES LAW

EXAMPLE

Imagine a scenario where Sarah, a resident of California, is walking alone late at night when a stranger suddenly approaches her in a menacing manner. The stranger aggressively reaches into his pocket, causing Sarah to fear for her safety. In response, Sarah grabs a nearby object, believing it to be a potential weapon, and strikes the stranger, causing him severe injury.

In this situation, Sarah may invoke self-defense as a legal justification for her actions. She genuinely believed that she was in immediate danger of being harmed or killed by the stranger’s aggressive behavior and reached into his pocket. Sarah reasonably believed that using force was necessary to protect herself from harm.

To remain within the bounds of the law, Sarah should ensure that she only used the amount of force that was reasonably necessary to neutralize the perceived threat. It is the responsibility of the legal system to assess the reasonableness of Sarah’s actions in accordance with California self-defense laws.

ASSESSING REASONABLE BELIEF IN CALIFORNIA SELF-DEFENSE CASES

To determine if a killing qualifies as self-defense in California, all circumstances relevant to the case are vital, as outlined in the California Penal Code Section 198. For instance, if the defendant had knowledge of the attacker’s criminal record or the past tendency of becoming violent when drunk, these factors are taken into consideration.

The reasonableness of the belief can also affect the assessment. In other words, the question that needs to be answered is whether a reasonable person in a similar position as the defendant, with the same information available, would reach the same belief.

If the answer is yes, then the belief can be deemed reasonable. The relevance of all the circumstances must be thoroughly considered to make a fair and accurate assessment of self-defense claims in California.

See also  FELONY CRIMES IN CALIFORNIA

LEGAL IMPLICATIONS OF UNREASONABLE BELIEF IN SELF-DEFENSE CASES

In some cases, a defendant may possess a belief that the threat level justifies the use of lethal force, but it turns out that the belief is unreasonable. This is known as imperfect self-defense in California.

Imperfect self-defense implies that while the killing was unlawful, it was committed without malice aforethought. As a result, the defendant cannot be charged with first-degree murder but can still face liability for second-degree murder or manslaughter.

It is important to note that the accuracy of the information on which the belief is based is not the determining factor for its reasonability. For instance, if someone’s spouse shoots an unfamiliar plumber because they genuinely believed the plumber was breaking in, even if that belief is ultimately proven to be incorrect, the spouse’s perception of feeling threatened in the moment can still be considered reasonable.

In cases of imperfect self-defense, the court will carefully examine the circumstances to determine the degree of culpability and whether the defendant’s belief, although unreasonable, can mitigate the charges they face.

IMMINENCE OF DANGER IN CALIFORNIA

In California, the imminence of danger is a critical determining factor in the assessment of self-defense cases. It is not sufficient to believe that the danger may occur in the near future.

For instance, a scenario where a person argues with their neighbor and the neighbor threatens to kill them while they sleep, provides an example. If the person retrieves a gun and goes after their neighbor to shoot them, it won’t be considered self-defense.

Legal standards require that the danger must be immediate and imminent for a claim of self-defense to be valid in California. Therefore, it is essential to establish the imminence of danger when assessing a self-defense claim.

See also  WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN 1ST AND 2ND DEGREE BURGLARY?

EXCESSIVE FORCE AND SELF-DEFENSE CLAIMS

In California, any use of force or malice that exceeds what is necessary to stop an aggressor can undermine a self-defense claim.

For example, if a thief breaks into your home and you are able to disarm or neutralize them, shooting them afterwards would not be considered self-defense.

It is important to avoid using more force than reasonably necessary when defending oneself. Using excessive force, such as shooting an already disarmed or neutralized aggressor, can complicate or invalidate a self-defense claim in California.

RELATED CRIMES

SPEAK WITH CRIMINAL DEFENSE LAWYER FROM TABIBNIA LAW FIRM

When charged with murder but having a valid claim of self-defense, it is crucial to seek assistance promptly. Many individuals are wrongfully convicted in similar situations, emphasizing the significance of having a prepared criminal defense lawyer.

Having the right legal representation can make all the difference between being charged with first-degree murder and successfully asserting self-defense. Therefore, if you are concerned about potential prosecution under California Penal Code Section 198 for a self-defense killing, it is advisable to contact the Tabibnia Law Firm.

Cyrus Tabibnia, an experienced criminal defense lawyer, is here to listen to your story and provide assistance. To schedule a case evaluation, please call 866-713-2159 and ensure you have the guidance necessary to navigate your situation effectively.

Sources:

California Code, Penal Code – PEN § 198

CHAPTER 1. Homicide [187 – 199]

CHAPTER 1 – Homicide Section 198.5

Cyrus Tabibnia

Cyrus Tabibnia

Cyrus Tabibnia, also known as Shahrooz Tabibnia, is a criminal defense lawyer in Los Angeles, California. With a law degree from Loyola Law School, Los Angeles, he has been practicing law since 2005 and holds license #237348. With over 18 years of experience, Cyrus specializes in various misdemeanor and felony criminal Law including Domestic Violence, Theft Crime, Sex crime, DUI & DWI, Personal Injury, Employment Law, and Cannabis & Marijuana Drugs Law. Being bilingual in English, Persian, and Spanish enables him to effectively communicate with a diverse range of clients. From 2014 to 2018, he served as a board member of the Iranian American Bar Association. An expungement attorney in Los Angeles who can assist you in clearing your criminal record in the state of California.

    Get A Case Review Today

    Please prove you are human by selecting the car.

    EXCELLENT rating
    Based on 39 reviews
    I would like to sincerely thank my attorney Cyrus Tabibnia and the Tabibnia Law firm for everything you have done for me and my family. Highly satisfied customers and excellent service is what you want when you hire an attorney. I was always treated with respect, if I needed anything or had any questions or concerns Mr. Tabibna was always available. I give a five-star rating as one of his clients and would honestly give a ten-star review if I could, because he is an awesome attorney worth every penny. I would highly recommend to anybody looking for a criminal defense attorney that Cyrus Tabibnia and his law firm be the one you consider
    Pharroh Knight
    Pharroh Knight
    2 April 2024
    Thank you for being so generous with your time and expertise and providing a legal consult! We really appreciate it
    Eli Elay
    Eli Elay
    6 February 2024
    My family had an urgent matter late on a Friday night. Cyrus took our call at 10p, listened to our situation, and answered all our questions. He was thorough in his explanations and addressed our concerns. What we appreciated the most was that he was not pushy and walked us through different approaches for our situation. We have not needed legal representation yet, but with Cyrus’ flexibility, transparency, and straight forwardness, we would highly recommend him.
    MICHELLE ROMAN
    MICHELLE ROMAN
    14 December 2023
    I had a DUI charge where I was having difficulties having an attorney give me the time of day to hear me about my case. I called different places and finally found Cyrus Tabibnia Law Firm a criminal Defense Attorney. I called him and he promptly returned my call. He sat down with me and listened to me, he understood my situation and gave me the peace of mind that lifted the stress I was going threw off my shoulders. He took control and walked me through everything. He explained the process of what to expect and what to do. Whenever I needed to talk to Cyrus, he made himself available to me. I was happy with the outcome of my case and would definitely recommend anyone to give Cyrus Tabibnia a call if they need a dependable criminal attorney to represent them.
    E T
    E T
    19 November 2023
    Mr. Cyrus Tabibnia has been outstanding in his knowledge and work related to legal matters. I have very much appreciated working with you.
    Rinah
    Rinah
    14 November 2023
    I have appreciated working professionally with Mr. Cyrus Tabibnia and his law firm on various cases that will assist his clients.
    Roxanna Rahban
    Roxanna Rahban
    14 November 2023
    Excellent Attorneys AND Customer service. They were patient, kind, and incredibly clear in their communications regarding my case and followed up promptly at each step of the process. I felt seen, heard and valued as a client and highly recommend this firm to anyone who is looking for kindness, professionalism and great results.
    Alexandra Sophia Marsalis
    Alexandra Sophia Marsalis
    14 November 2023
    Dedicated Attorney I have had the privilege of knowing attorney Cyrus Tabibnia since 2010, when he used to be a dedicated Board member at our local Bar Association in Los Angeles. He has always been respected by his colleagues for his legal contribution to the members of the Bar Association. While interacting with him professionally, I have found him to be a man of integrity, a competent counsel and zealous advocate for his clients in a variety of civil and criminal cases. Despite his busy professional schedule, Cyrus adheres to his family values and keeps his precious friendship with the rest of us. I am honored to call Cyrus a colleague and endorse him for the services that he offers to the public.
    Zaher Fallahi
    Zaher Fallahi
    14 November 2023
    I endorse the Tabibnia Law Firm. Mr. Tabibnia is colleague and staunch professional. He is clearly dedicated to his clients, craft, and practice. Do not hesitate to reach out to Mr. Tabibnia for services.
    Daniel Forouzan
    Daniel Forouzan
    10 November 2023

    Recent Posts

    Practice Areas

    Locations We Serve